Facing a neighborhood conflict, unpaid rent, a contested dismissal, or a commercial dispute? The first question that arises is always the same: which court should you turn to? In France, the judicial organization can seem like a real labyrinth for the uninitiated, especially since successive reforms have deeply modified the map and jurisdiction of the courts. Choosing the wrong court means risking a waste of precious time, seeing your claim dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, and having to bear unnecessary procedural costs. This comprehensive guide, written by the experts at AvocatAI, gives you all the keys to instantly identify the right court for your dispute and initiate your procedures with peace of mind.
---
To understand which court has jurisdiction, you must first understand the major division of justice in France. The French legal system is based on a strict separation between two major legal orders: the judicial order and the administrative order.
As soon as your dispute opposes you to a public entity (the State, a town hall, a prefecture, a public university, a public hospital), the administrative justice system has jurisdiction.
The judicial order deals with all conflicts arising between private parties (individuals, associations, commercial companies). This order is itself divided into two branches:
---
Since January 1, 2020, the Tribunaux d'Instance (TI - Local Courts) and the Tribunaux de Grande Instance (TGI - High Courts) have merged to create the "Tribunal Judiciaire" (TJ - Judicial Court). When a town did not have a TGI but had a TI, the latter became a detached chamber of the Judicial Court, called the "Tribunal de Proximité" (Local Court).
To determine which civil court to petition, two cumulative rules apply: subject-matter jurisdiction (ratione materiae) linked to the nature of the case, and territorial jurisdiction (ratione loci) linked to geography.
The Tribunal Judiciaire is the common law court for civil matters. According to Article L. 211-3 of the Code de l'organisation judiciaire (Judicial Organization Code), it has jurisdiction over all disputes that are not assigned by law to another court.
The financial amount of the dispute (the "jurisdictional threshold") determines the composition of the court:
Certain areas are exclusively assigned to the Tribunal Judiciaire, regardless of the amount at stake:
This is a specialized judge within the Tribunal Judiciaire or Tribunal de Proximité. They are specifically competent for:
> Concrete Example No. 1: The Rental Dispute
> Marie rents an apartment in Paris for a rent of €900 per month. Upon her departure, her landlord refuses to return her security deposit of €900, claiming damage not justified by the move-in inventory (état des lieux d'entrée).
> Which court? Since the dispute concerns a residential lease, the Juge des Contentieux de la Protection (JCP) of the Tribunal de Proximité* of the location of the property has exclusive jurisdiction, even though the amount is under €10,000.
> * Lawyer? Not mandatory. Marie can defend herself or be assisted by a relative or a legal professional.
The Conseil de Prud'hommes (French labor tribunal) is a joint court (composed of equal numbers of elected employer and employee judges) that settles individual disputes arising from private-law employment contracts (Article L. 1411-1 of the Code du travail [Labor Code]).
Composed of consular judges (traders elected by their peers), the Tribunal de Commerce (Commercial Court) has jurisdiction over:
---
Once you know the nature of the court (Judicial, Commercial, Labor), you must determine its geographical location.
The basic rule in French law (Article 42 of the Code de procédure civile) is extremely clear: the court with territorial jurisdiction is the one of the place where the defendant resides (the person you are suing). If your opponent lives in Lyon, you must petition the court in Lyon, even if you live in Lille.
However, there are major protective exceptions:
1. In contractual matters: You can choose the court of the place of the actual delivery of the goods or the place of the performance of the service (Article 46 of the CPC).
2. In consumer matters: The consumer may petition, at their choice, the court of the place where they resided at the time the contract was concluded or when the harmful event occurred (Article R. 631-3 of the Code de la consommation [Consumer Code]).
3. In real estate matters: For disputes relating to real property (lease, co-ownership), the competent court is exclusively the one where the property is located.
---
Going to court cannot be improvised. Here is the typical path to effectively initiate a civil lawsuit.
```
[Step 1: Attempted Conciliation]
│
▼
[Step 2: Drafting the Saisine (Summons or Petition)]
│
▼
[Step 3: Notification by a Commissaire de justice (if summons)]
│
▼
[Step 4: Enrôlement (filing the case file with the court registry)]
│
▼
[Step 5: Hearing and Deliberation]
```
For disputes under €5,000 or for neighborhood conflicts (boundaries, planting distances, abnormal neighborhood disturbances), the law imposes an attempted conciliation, mediation, or a procédure de procédure participative (collaborative procedure) before any petition is made to the court (Article 750-1 of the Code de procédure civile).
If conciliation fails, you must draft your claim:
If you proceed by assignation, you must call upon a Commissaire de justice (formerly huissier de justice - bailiff) to officially deliver the act to your opponent. The cost of service generally varies between €80 and €150 depending on the acts and urgency.
Once the summons has been delivered, you (or your lawyer) must transmit it to the court registry so that the case is registered on the rôle (the hearing schedule).
On the day of the hearing, the parties present their arguments. The judge very rarely renders their decision immediately: they place the case "under deliberation" (en délibéré) and announce the date on which the judgment will be available at the registry.
---
To avoid the statute of limitations on your action and to budget your procedure, keep these essential figures in mind:
> Concrete Example No. 2: The Renovation Dispute
> Pierre has a heat pump installed by a professional for an amount of €12,500. The device breaks down after two weeks and the installer refuses to intervene.
> Which court? The amount of the dispute exceeds €10,000. Pierre must petition the Tribunal Judiciaire*.
> * Lawyer? Yes, representation by a lawyer is mandatory here because the amount is greater than €10,000.
> Prior step: Pierre is not subject to the mandatory prior conciliation obligation of Article 750-1 because the amount is greater than €5,000, but sending a formal notice (mise en demeure*) by registered letter remains indispensable.
---
---
For abnormal neighborhood disturbances, the competent court is the Tribunal de Proximité or the Tribunal Judiciaire of the place where the property is located. Please note that for this type of dispute, a prior amicable conciliation attempt conducted by a justice conciliator is strictly mandatory, regardless of the estimated amount of the damage.
If you make a mistake, the judge petitioned will declare themselves "incompetent" (incompétent). Depending on the case, they may refer the file directly to the court they deem competent, or invite you to re-summon your opponent before the correct jurisdiction. In any case, this will result in a considerable loss of time (often several months) and additional procedural costs.
Since January 1, 2020, representation by a lawyer has become mandatory before the Tribunal de Commerce for disputes where the financial stake is greater than €10,000, or for unspecified claims. Below this amount, you can defend yourself or be assisted by any person of your choice holding a special power of attorney (company employee, spouse, etc.).
If you are not satisfied with the first-instance judgment, you can appeal to the Cour d'Appel (Court of Appeal). However, an appeal is only possible if the amount of the dispute is greater than €5,000 (the jurisdictional threshold). Below €5,000, the judgment is rendered "in last resort" (en dernier ressort): you cannot appeal. Your only recourse is then an appeal to the Cour de Cassation (Supreme Court), which will not retry the case on its merits but will only verify if the law was correctly applied by the first judge.
---
Legal information for guidance only, not personalised legal advice. For your specific situation, ask your question free of charge on AvocatAI — answers based on French law, in your language.