The inventory of fixtures—known in France as the état des lieux—at the start or end of a tenancy is often a source of intense tension between tenants and landlords. This document, which may seem trivial when signing the lease or handing over the keys, actually holds immense legal power: it alone determines whether the landlord or the tenant must pay for property repairs. Whether you are a tenant who feels unfairly accused of causing damage or a landlord facing a bad-faith occupant, a disputed état des lieux is not a dead end. By mastering the rules of French law and adopting the right reflexes, you can restore fairness and protect your rights.
---
To defend yourself effectively, you must first understand the rules of the game. In France, rental relationships for primary residences (unfurnished or furnished) are governed by Loi n° 89-462 du 6 juillet 1989 (Law No. 89-462 of July 6, 1989). This fundamental statute lays down the rules for the état des lieux and the return of the dépôt de garantie (security deposit).
According to Article 3-2 of the Law of July 6, 1989, the état des lieux must be established jointly and contradictorily by both parties (or by a third party authorized by them) and attached to the tenancy agreement. "Contradictory" means that each party must have the opportunity to express their agreement or disagreement on every single observation. The état des lieux must be drawn up in writing, either on paper or in electronic format, and each party must receive a copy immediately after signing it.
This distinction lies at the heart of most disputes. The tenant is required to return the property in the condition in which they received it, except for what has deteriorated due to vétusté (fair wear and tear).
If no incoming inventory (état des lieux d'entrée) was carried out, *Article 1731 of the Code civil (French Civil Code)* establishes a formidable principle: "If no inventory of fixtures has been made, the tenant is presumed to have received them in good tenantable repair, and must return them as such, unless there is proof to the contrary."
However, this presumption does not apply if the landlord prevented the état des lieux from being carried out.
---
If, on the day of the inspection, you notice that the landlord (or the estate agent) is writing down details you do not agree with, you have several options.
This is your absolute right. If the other party refuses to note down your remarks or describes as "very poor condition" what you consider to be "normal worn condition," do not sign the document. A signature at the bottom of the document constitutes definitive acceptance of the findings. If you sign "under reserve" (avec réserves), be aware that this mention carries very weak and uncertain legal weight in court.
If one of the parties refuses to sign, or if communication has completely broken down, you must call upon a commissaire de justice (bailiff/judicial officer).
---
If you signed the état des lieux under pressure, if it contains errors, or if the landlord is unfairly withholding your security deposit after your departure, here is the legal path to follow.
```
[Step 1: Formal Notice by Registered Mail (LRAR)]
│
▼
[Step 2: Referral to the CDC (Free of charge)] ──(Agreement?)──► [End of Dispute (Written Agreement)]
│
(No Agreement)
▼
[Step 3: Referral to the Juge des Contentieux de la Protection]
```
As soon as you identify the dispute (for example, upon receiving an incorrect état des lieux or when deductions are made from your security deposit), you must send a letter of formal notice via registered mail with acknowledgment of receipt (lettre recommandée avec accusé de réception - LRAR) to the other party.
In this letter, you must:
If the formal notice remains unanswered or if the response is unsatisfactory, you must refer the matter to the CDC (County Conciliation Commission) of your department. This process is free of charge and is mandatory for security deposit disputes before you can take the matter to court (for amounts under €5,000).
If conciliation fails, or if you choose to bypass the CDC (which is possible for certain specific disputes, though prior conciliation is highly recommended), you must refer the matter to the Juge des contentieux de la protection (protection litigation judge) at the local court (tribunal de proximité) where the property is located. You have 3 years from the day the security deposit should have been returned to initiate this action.
---
To avoid losing your rights through negligence, here are the strict legal timeframes and figures currently in force in France:
---
The Situation: Marie rented an apartment for 8 years. During the outgoing inspection, the landlord notes that the living room paint is "faded and yellowed." He decides to withhold the entire cost of repainting from Marie's security deposit, amounting to €1,200 on a €900 deposit, and demands an additional €300.
Marie's Defense: Marie disputes this. She relies on a wear-and-tear grid (grille de vétusté), which is often annexed to the lease or recognized by courts. For paintwork, the average lifespan is generally estimated at 7 to 9 years with an initial write-off period. After 8 years, the residual value of the paint is only 10%.
The Situation: Thomas moves out of his flat on June 30. The outgoing état des lieux is perfectly identical to the incoming one. His rent was €600 excluding charges. The landlord had 1 month (until July 31) to return his security deposit of €600. The landlord only returns the money on October 15, without justification.
Thomas's Defense: The delay is 2 and a half months (August, September, and any part of October started).
---
---
In principle, no. Your signature on the état des lieux expresses your definitive agreement with its contents. However, there are exceptions: if you can prove you signed under duress or threat, or if you report hidden defects or non-visible issues (such as blocked pipes or a broken appliance) in writing (via LRAR) within 10 days of moving in.
No. If the outgoing état des lieux states that the property is "clean" (propre) or in a condition similar to when you moved in, the landlord cannot make any deduction for cleaning costs. Any deduction must be rigorously justified by a written difference noted between the incoming and outgoing inspections.
If the landlord does not show up or refuses to set an appointment, you should not simply leave the keys in the letterbox. You must call a commissaire de justice (bailiff) to carry out the rental inventory. This will protect you from being accused later of damage that occurred after your departure.
Wear-and-tear grids are not uniformly imposed by law, but the tenant and landlord can agree to apply one when signing the lease (chosen from those established by a national collective agreement). Even in the absence of a signed grid, courts always refer to the theoretical lifespan of equipment to calculate the depreciation of property.
---
---
Legal information for guidance only, not personalised legal advice. For your specific situation, ask your question free of charge on AvocatAI — answers based on French law, in your language.