You have just received a court decision and the verdict does not suit you, or seems profoundly unfair. In French law, the principle of double degree of jurisdiction (double degré de juridiction) allows your case to be re-examined by a higher court: the Cour d'appel (Court of Appeal). However, embarking on this path is not something to be done lightly, as the appeal process is bound by strict formal rules, tight deadlines, and specific costs. This comprehensive guide written by AvocatAI explains in detail how to appeal a judgment, the deadlines to respect, the effects of this process, and the pitfalls to avoid.
---
An appeal is an ordinary legal remedy by which a party to a lawsuit asks the Cour d'appel to overturn or annul the judgment rendered in the first instance by a court (such as the Tribunal judiciaire (Judicial Court), Tribunal de commerce (Commercial Court), Conseil de prud'hommes (Labour Tribunal), etc.).
The double degré de juridiction (double degree of jurisdiction) is a fundamental principle of French justice. It guarantees litigants that their case can be judged a second time, both on the facts (en fait) and on the law (en droit), by more experienced magistrates (the conseillers (judges) of the Court of Appeal). The Court of Appeal will retry the case: it re-examines the evidence and legal arguments, and can either confirm the first judgment or modify it (referred to as an arrêt infirmatif (overturning decision)).
Not all court decisions can be appealed. French law distinguishes between two situations:
---
Respecting deadlines is the golden rule when it comes to appeals. A delay of just one single day will render your appeal irrecevable (inadmissible), meaning the Court of Appeal will refuse to examine your file and the first judgment will become final and incontestable.
The deadline to appeal does not start running on the day the judgment is delivered (pronounced), but on the day it is officially notified to you.
Deadlines vary depending on the nature of the dispute (civil, criminal, administrative):
If you reside abroad and need to appeal a decision rendered by a French court, French law grants additional time to account for postal distances and geographical remoteness.
---
Appealing a court decision produces two major legal effects that must be fully understood.
In principle, according to Article 539 of the Code de procédure civile, recourse through an ordinary path (such as an appeal) is suspensive (suspensif). This means that the execution of the first-instance judgment is suspended as long as the appeal deadline has not expired and, if an appeal is filed, until the Court of Appeal has rendered its decision. You do not have to pay the sums requested or execute the obligations set by the first judge during this period.
*WARNING regarding the major exception: Provisional execution by law (exécution provisoire de droit).*
Since the justice reform that entered into force on January 1, 2020 (Article 514 of the Code de procédure civile), provisional execution is now the rule for first-instance decisions. This means that even if you appeal, you must execute the judgment immediately (pay damages, vacate a property, etc.), unless you obtain a stay of this provisional execution from the Premier président (First President) of the Court of Appeal by demonstrating that it would lead to manifestly excessive consequences.
Article 561 of the Code de procédure civile states that an appeal transfers the knowledge of the dispute to the Court so that it may be decided again in fact and in law. However, this effect is limited by the "devolutive effect" (effet dévolutif): the Court of Appeal can only judge what is expressly submitted to it. The appellant must specify in their declaration of appeal (déclaration d'appel) the specific parts of the judgment they are challenging (unless the appeal aims for the total annulment of the judgment). Furthermore, it is in principle forbidden to submit new claims on appeal (Article 564 of the Code de procédure civile), except to counter the opposing party's claims or to resolve issues arising from the intervention of a third party.
---
To better understand the practical application of these rules, here are two case studies.
Marie rents an apartment in Paris for a rent of 900 € per month. Following a conflict with her landlord regarding uncompleted repairs, she stops paying her rent for several months. The landlord takes the matter to the Tribunal judiciaire, which, in a judgment rendered on October 15, orders Marie to pay 4,500 € in rent arrears and orders the termination of the lease.
John, a British national residing in London, sold goods to a French company for a value of 12,000 €. The French buyer refuses to pay, citing a lack of conformity. The Tribunal de commerce of Lyon rules in favour of the French buyer in a judgment dated June 1.
---
The appeal procedure before the Court of Appeal is essentially written and highly formalistic. Here are the 5 key steps to successfully carry out this action.
Upon receiving the service of the judgment, read the decision carefully. Analyse the judge's reasoning. Ask yourself if the financial cost of an appeal procedure (lawyer's fees, taxes) is worth it compared to the expected gain.
In the vast majority of cases before the Court of Appeal (particularly in civil and commercial matters), representation by a lawyer is mandatory (représentation obligatoire). You must mandate a lawyer registered with the bar of the jurisdiction of the relevant Court of Appeal (called an avocat postulant) or a lawyer from another bar who will associate with a local postulant.
Your lawyer will draft a déclaration d'appel (declaration of appeal). This legal document must contain mandatory information under penalty of nullity, including the identification of the parties, references of the challenged judgment, and above all, the precise list of the challenged parts of the judgment (the specific points of the judgment you contest). The declaration of appeal is transmitted electronically to the registry of the Court of Appeal via the secure RPVA network (the French lawyers' communication network).
For your appeal to be admissible in civil and commercial matters (where representation by a lawyer is mandatory), you must pay a fiscal stamp duty (droit de timbre) of 225 € (Article 1635 bis P of the Code général des impôts (General Tax Code)). This stamp can be purchased online. Certain cases are exempt, notably if you benefit from legal aid (aide juridictionnelle).
Once the appeal is registered, a race against the clock begins for the lawyers, subject to strict deadlines known as the "Magendie deadlines" (Articles 908 et seq. of the Code de procédure civile):
Failure to respect these deadlines leads to the lapse (caducité) of the declaration of appeal or the inadmissibility of the arguments.
---
---
In principle, no. Before the Court of Appeal ruling on civil, commercial, or social matters, representation by a lawyer is mandatory. There are very rare exceptions (for example, in social protection litigation or agricultural leases under certain conditions), but the assistance of a professional remains highly recommended due to the complexity of the appeal procedure.
If you file your appeal even one day after the expiration of the legal deadline, your appeal will be declared inadmissible (irrecevable) automatically by the pre-trial judge (conseiller de la mise en état). The first judgment then acquires the "authority of a final ruling" (autorité de la chose jugée) and becomes final. There is no recourse to recover an expired appeal deadline, except in extremely rare and difficult-to-prove cases of force majeure.
When you appeal a judgment (you are the main appellant), your opponent (the respondent) can decide, in response to your recourse, to also contest other points of the judgment that did not suit them. This is called an appel incident (cross-appeal). The cross-appeal is subject to the same strict requirements as the main appeal.
The appeal procedure is generally longer than that of the first instance. Due to the backlog in French courts of appeal and the formal nature of exchanging written arguments, the average processing time for a case varies between 12 and 24 months depending on the region and the complexity of the case.
---
Legal information for guidance only, not personalised legal advice. For your specific situation, ask your question free of charge on AvocatAI — answers based on French law, in your language.