Legal Warranty of Conformity: 2 Years to Claim Your Rights

Have you just bought a smartphone that refuses to turn on after a few months of use, or a washing machine that leaks the very first time you use it? In France, you do not have to pay for manufacturing defects in your products thanks to an ultra-protective legal shield: the garantie légale de conformité (legal warranty of conformity). This public order mechanism requires professional sellers to deliver goods that conform to the contract and to answer for any defects existing at the time of delivery. Here is a complete breakdown of this fundamental consumer right so you know how to take effective action during this crucial two-year period.

---

What is the Legal Warranty of Conformity?

The garantie légale de conformité is a statutory obligation imposed on any professional seller towards an individual buyer (consumer). Unlike commercial warranties or paid "extended warranties" offered by retailers, the legal warranty is entirely free of charge and mandatory. The seller cannot charge for it, reduce it, or exclude it from their general terms and conditions of sale.

Legal Foundations in the Consumer Code

This warranty is governed by Articles L. 217-1 et seq. of the Code de la consommation (French Consumer Code).

According to Article L. 217-3 of the Code de la consommation:

> "The seller delivers goods conforming to the contract as well as to the criteria set out in Article L. 217-5 and answers for conformity defects existing at the time of delivery."

For a product to be considered conforming, it must meet several cumulative criteria defined by Article L. 217-5:

• Be fit for the purpose usually expected of similar goods.
• Match the description given by the seller (physical characteristics, features).
• Possess the qualities that a buyer can legitimately expect in view of public statements made by the seller (advertising, labelling).
• Possess the specific qualities sought by the buyer, made known to the seller and accepted by the latter.

Which Goods Are Covered?

The warranty applies to a very wide range of products purchased in France (in-store or online from a website operating in France):

• New tangible movable goods (household appliances, computers, furniture, clothing, cars, etc.).
• Second-hand goods (subject to specific presumption periods).
• Goods containing digital elements (smartphones, smartwatches, computers).
• Digital content and services (streaming subscriptions, software).
• Goods to be manufactured or produced (custom-made furniture).

---

The 2-Year Deadline to Act and the Presumption of Non-Conformity

The timeframe for taking action is the pillar of this protection. The rules differ slightly depending on whether the product was purchased new or second-hand.

The Limitation Period: 2 Years

Article L. 217-3 of the Code de la consommation states that action resulting from a lack of conformity lapses 2 years after the delivery of the goods. It is the date of physical delivery (or hand-delivery in-store) that prevails, not the order or invoice date.

The Presumption of Prior Existence of the Defect: The Key Point

This is the major advantage for the consumer, formalised in Article L. 217-7 of the Code de la consommation. During this period, the consumer does not have to prove that the defect existed at the time of purchase. The law presumes that the defect was present from the very beginning.

• For new goods: The presumption of prior existence is 2 years (24 months). If your new television breaks down after 23 months, the law considers that the defect existed at the time of purchase. It is up to the seller to prove otherwise (for example, by demonstrating that you dropped the device).
• For second-hand goods: The presumption of prior existence is 12 months (law applicable since 1 January 2022, compared to 6 months previously). If you buy a second-hand phone from a professional, any defect appearing within the first 12 months is presumed to have existed at the time of sale. Between the 13th month and the 24th month, the warranty still applies, but it is up to you, the buyer, to provide proof that the defect does not result from improper use on your part.

---

Available Solutions: Repair, Replacement, or Refund

When a lack of conformity is found, Article L. 217-8 of the Code de la consommation offers several options to the consumer.

Step 1: Choosing Between Repair and Replacement

The consumer can choose between having the item repaired or replaced.

However, the seller may refuse the buyer's choice if that choice entails a cost that is manifestly disproportionate to the other option, taking into account the value of the goods or the significance of the defect. If both options are impossible (for example, if the product is permanently out of stock and irreparable), we move to the next step.

Step 2: Price Reduction or Rescission of the Contract (Refund)

The consumer is entitled to a reduction in the price of the goods or the rescission of the contract (return of the goods in exchange for a full refund) in the following cases (Article L. 217-14):

1. If the seller refuses to repair or replace the item.

2. If the repair or replacement could not be carried out within 30 days following the claim.

3. If the repair or replacement causes major inconvenience to the consumer.

4. If the lack of conformity persists despite the seller's attempt to bring the item into compliance.

Important note: Rescission of the contract cannot be granted if the lack of conformity is minor (for example, a slight cosmetic scratch that does not prevent normal use).

---

Concrete Examples of Application

Example 1: Thomas's Laptop (New Good)

Thomas buys a new laptop for 1,200 € from a French e-commerce site. After 18 months, the graphics card suddenly burns out without any impact or drop.

• Application of the warranty: The 2-year deadline has not passed. The 24-month presumption of prior existence applies. Thomas does not have to prove anything.
• Resolution: Thomas requests a replacement laptop. Since the seller no longer has this model in stock, they offer a repair within 30 days. If the repair takes 45 days, Thomas is entitled to demand a full refund of his 1,200 € for exceeding the legal 30-day limit.

Example 2: Sofia's Second-Hand Car (Second-Hand Good)

Sofia buys a second-hand car from a professional garage for 8,500 €.

• Scenario A (Breakdown in the 8th month): The gearbox breaks after 8 months. The defect appears during the 12-month presumption period applicable to second-hand goods. The garage owner must fully cover the repairs (parts and labour), unless they can prove that Sofia drove the vehicle in an abnormally destructive manner.
• Scenario B (Breakdown in the 15th month): The gearbox breaks after 15 months. The 2-year action period has not expired, but the 12-month presumption has passed. Sofia must have the vehicle inspected by an expert at her own expense to demonstrate that the gearbox failure is due to abnormal wear or a defect prior to the sale in order to win her case.

---

Practical Steps: How to Take Action Step-by-Step

If you notice a defect in your product, follow these steps carefully to assert your rights.

Step 1: Gather Proof of Purchase

Find your invoice, receipt, or delivery slip. This document is essential to prove the date of delivery of the goods (the starting point of the 2 years) and the identity of the professional seller.

Step 2: Contact the Professional Seller

Contact the seller directly (and not the manufacturer of the product). The final seller is legally responsible for the warranty of conformity. You can go to the store or contact customer service by phone or email.

Step 3: Send a Written Formal Notice

If customer service refuses to apply the warranty or delays in responding, send a lettre recommandée avec accusé de réception (registered letter with acknowledgment of receipt, or LRAR).

• Expressly mention Articles L. 217-3 et seq. of the Code de la consommation.
• Describe the malfunction in detail.
• Formally demand that the seller repair or replace the item within 30 days at no cost to you.

Step 4: Contact a Consumer Mediator

If the seller maintains their refusal or ignores your LRAR, you must attempt an amicable resolution before taking legal action. The contact details of the médiateur de la consommation (consumer mediator) chosen by the professional must appear on their website or in their conditions générales de vente (general terms and conditions of sale, or CGV). This process is entirely free of charge for the consumer.

Step 5: Bring the Case Before the Judicial Court

If mediation fails, you can take the matter to the competent court. For consumer disputes:

• For an amount less than or equal to 10,000 €, you can petition the Tribunal judiciaire (Judicial Court) by simple request.
• The assistance of an avocat (lawyer) is not mandatory, but highly recommended for complex cases.

---

Mistakes to Avoid

• Allowing yourself to be redirected to the manufacturer: This is the most common mistake. Sellers often try to offload their responsibility by asking you to directly contact the manufacturer's after-sales service. The law is clear: your only legal contact is the seller from whom you bought the product.
• Paying shipping or labour costs: Article L. 217-13 of the Code de la consommation specifies that bringing the goods into compliance must be done at no cost to the consumer. The seller must cover return costs (postage, courier) and labour costs.
• Confusing the warranty of conformity with a commercial warranty: Do not be intimidated by a seller who claims that "the 1-year manufacturer's warranty has expired". The 2-year legal warranty of conformity is a matter of public order and is in addition to any other commercial warranty.
• Exceeding the 2-year deadline while negotiating: Informal discussions with customer service do not suspend the 2-year limitation period. If the deadline is approaching, you must send a formal notice or initiate legal action to interrupt the limitation period.

---

FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)

Does the warranty apply if I have lost the receipt?

The warranty remains valid, but you must be able to prove your purchase and its date by any other means. A bank statement showing the transaction to the store, a loyalty card registered during the purchase, or an order confirmation email can serve as acceptable alternative proof.

What happens to the warranty period if my product is repaired or replaced?

The law protects consumers against endless repairs. Article L. 217-11 provides that any suspension of the warranty during the repair period (if it lasts more than 7 days) extends the remaining warranty period by the same amount. Furthermore, if the item is repaired under warranty, it benefits from a 6-month warranty extension. If the item is replaced, a new 2-year legal warranty of conformity starts running from the date of delivery of the new item.

Can I claim the warranty if I broke the product myself?

No. The warranty of conformity does not cover defects resulting from an accident, negligence, misuse, lack of maintenance, or modification of the product by the consumer. If the seller proves that the breakdown is due to a fall or water damage not covered by the user manual, the warranty will be refused.

Does the warranty apply to transactions between private individuals?

No. The legal warranty of conformity applies exclusively to relations between a professional seller and an individual consumer. If you buy a second-hand item from a private individual (on platforms like Le Bon Coin or Vinted), you cannot invoke this warranty. You only have access to the garantie légale des vices cachés (legal warranty against hidden defects) under Articles 1641 et seq. of the Code civil (French Civil Code), for which the burden of proof is much more difficult to establish.

---

In Summary

• The legal warranty of conformity is free, mandatory, and lasts for 2 years from the delivery of the product.
• A defect that appears within 24 months for a new product (and 12 months for a second-hand product) is presumed to have existed from the time of purchase.
• The consumer can demand repair or replacement of the defective product as a priority.
• All costs (return, labour, parts) are entirely borne by the seller.
• The professional seller is your sole legal contact; they cannot redirect you to the manufacturer.

Legal information for guidance only, not personalised legal advice. For your specific situation, ask your question free of charge on AvocatAI — answers based on French law, in your language.